Can only speak YJ.....but 35 X 12.50 will kill that dana35 even a ZJ variant.....
33 X 10.50 is a lot smaller and a LOT lighter
I know it's your off-roader but my rig was sprightly on 33 X 12.50 and a slug on 35x12.50
Fuel went from 18 down to 14 on a good day.......
But hell it was fun......
And now it's even better